Good morning, Alex
Your plan — $198.17 a month
Where you’re heading
$402,920
by the time your mortgage ends — year 30.
Your original goal: $413,284 — the figure this plan was set to reach.
What the bank charges — and what the plan makes it.
Your mortgage: $500,000 at 4.00% — $2,377.59 a month · 28 years of amortization left · estimated balance today about $481,931, on regular payments
At about 10% a year — what a dollar left alone earned across the whole record.
Your original goal — the plan’s path — figured three different years. It barely moves.
The rate behind these numbers
The rate used on this page: 10.06% a year.
It’s not a made-up number. It is what it is — what the market actually returned on a dollar left alone. $1 invested at the start of 1928, dividends reinvested, grew to about $11,976 by the end of 2025. Spread evenly across the whole record, that works out to 10.06% a year.
It isn’t the only figure the record offers. Here is the whole shelf — every number below figured from the same 1928–2025 record, with the one in use marked. It isn’t the highest on the shelf:
In 80% of the 30-year stretches since 1928, the return was greater than the 10.06% used here — 55 of the 69 stretches, counted one by one. Of the 14 that fell under it, 11 landed between 9.43% and 10.02% — near-misses, not disasters. Only three form the true tail, and every one of them began into the Great Depression: 7.97%, 7.97% and 8.70%.
No 30-year stretch has ever lost money — but no single year inside them looked like 10% either. Picking one stretch lets you prove almost anything; this page uses the whole record instead — the Depression, the 1970s, 2008, and the good decades too.
Add or drop the most recent years and it barely moves — that’s the point of using the whole record.
How your original goal is figured
Your deposit is $198.17 a month — one mortgage payment a year ($2,377.59) spread over twelve months.
It’s figured as 360 deposits, one at the end of each month for 30 years.
Each deposit grows at 0.8017% a month. That’s the monthly rate that builds to exactly 10.06% over a full year — the rate figured above, from a dollar left alone across the whole record. (Dividing the yearly rate by 12 would quietly assume more than the record shows; this page doesn’t.)
Deposits in: $71,341. Growth on them: $341,943. Together: $413,284.
An illustration from history’s whole record — not a forecast or a guarantee, and before fees and taxes.
Source: S&P 500 annual returns, dividends reinvested, 1928–2025 — Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern (Damodaran Online), “Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds and Bills”. The whole record, compounded — not a forecast, and not a guarantee. Before fees and taxes. Your own years will be bumpier than this line — see What to expect on the way.
The comparison that matters
Both run to year 30 on the same $198.17 a month. One buys interest savings at 4%. The other follows the long-run rate.
Where you are today
This plan is valued at market close. If you buy during the day, your price will differ a little — that’s timing, not the plan.
Why is my number different?
Your number today is $4,513. The long-run path says $5,221.
The whole difference is $708, and it comes from one thing: year 2 was a down year, and your early deposits shrank with the market. The plan’s path is a smooth long-run line — real life isn’t.
This plan is valued at market close. If you buy during the day, your price will differ a little — that’s timing, not the plan.
Update my balance
Your account will show its own number. Enter it here and this page will use yours. Your number today follows the index — $4,513 (45.1649 units × 99.9320).
Showing the index figure.
Grown over the remaining 28 years, that $708 is why the ending figure re-figures to about $402,920 instead of $413,284.
Your original goal is $413,284. Where you’re heading is $402,920 — $10,364 behind the goal.
From here, reaching your original goal would need the remaining years to average 10.19% — the plan is figured at 10.06%.
50 of the 69 thirty-year stretches in the record — 72% — returned more than that.
Your plan’s average so far — your real months blended with the average figured for the months left: 9.03%.
The comparison that matters: these same deposits, given to the bank as extra mortgage payments, end at about $135,800 of value.
Don’t get too excited, and don’t get too down. The part you control is the deposits — 24 made, 336 to go.
Try a different amount
Your plan: $198.17 a month, set with Ernie. The deposit is yours to choose — one client freed up $1,000 a month in a refinance and chose to invest $700 of it; the plan then tracks the $700. Slide to see what a different amount does.
From the start, at $198 a month: $413,284What-if
Put in $71,341 + growth $341,943, by year 30.
From where the path stands today: $413,284
Today’s path balance ($5,221) grown on, plus $198 a month for the 336 months left.
Term 1 of 6 · Year 2 · Deposit 24 of 360
This plan runs in 5-year terms, like your mortgage. We review it together at every renewal.
The gap isn’t the market. It’s the interruption.
I came across a book this month — Barry Ritholtz’s How Not to Invest, by way of a podcast — and it sent me back to a study I keep returning to. Morningstar measures something most people never see: over the ten years to the end of 2024, the funds themselves returned 8.2% a year. The people invested in those very same funds earned 7.0%. Same funds. Same decade.
The difference has a name — the behavior gap — and it isn’t about picking the wrong fund. It’s the deposits that stop when life happens, the money that moves after a scary headline, the plan that gets paused, just for now. A planner named Carl Richards coined the term; Ben Carlson wrote a whole book on the reasons. They all land in the same place: the returns are there. People interrupt them.
That’s why your plan is built the way it is: a deposit small enough that a car repair doesn’t knock it off course, taken automatically, so there’s no decision to make in a bad month. $198 doesn’t compete with new brakes. That isn’t an accident — it’s the design.
So if this month’s number is up, don’t get too excited. If it’s down, don’t get too down. Keep the deposit on. That’s the whole job.
— Ernie
Investing the deposit instead of paying the mortgage down — figured on payoff day, year 26. A comparison, not a new rate. Yours doesn’t change.
A mortgage at 1.92% would cost exactly that $135,178 over the same 312 months — that’s where the 1.92% comes from. Your contract rate stays 4.00%.
What to expect on the way
“Volatility is the price of admission. The prize inside is superior long-term returns. You have to pay the price to get the returns.”
— Morgan Housel, The Psychology of Money
Volatility is a fee, not a fine.
WHAT THE MARKET ACTUALLY DID — by how long you stayed in
Every stretch there has been since 1928, figured per year. The average barely moves. The spread collapses.
S&P 500 total return, dividends reinvested, 1928–2025.
The antidote is time in the market
Time doesn’t raise the average — it removes the disasters.
You’ve been in 2 years. A typical 30 years holds about 7 down years. You’ve met one of them — the fee being collected, right on schedule.
The deposits. 24 made · 336 to go · next one November 30.
Don’t get too excited, and don’t get too down based on your current number.
Basis: S&P 500 total return, 1928–2025. An illustration from history — not a forecast, and not a guarantee.
What if a bad year comes?
Bad years are coming — they always do. These are the worst the record has, placed at hard moments in your plan’s life.
Here is what they would have done to your plan, on your own numbers, in mortgage terms: what would be in the account on payoff day, what would still be owing, whether it covers it — and what your mortgage would have effectively cost.
Down 43.84% — the worst single year in the record.
Covers the payoff 1.39× — $41,197 left over after settling
Your contract rate is 4.00% — and it doesn’t change.
Figured from today: from your balance today, with the deposits continuing, at the plan’s figured rate of 10.06% before and after the bad year. The bad years are the record’s own, from the same 1928–2025 record used on this page. The panel above figures your effective rate from the plan’s start; this section figures from today, so the two need not match. An illustration, not a prediction.
And if the worst year came last
The paydown figures save the whole mortgage payment — $2,377.59 a month — every month, once the mortgage is gone.
There’s a graph that goes with this — what happened to money put in at the very top, in 1929, 1973, 2000 and 2008. It needs a bigger screen: look for it on the desktop version of this page.
What if you’d put a lump sum in at the very top?
Each line is $10,000 invested the day before a famous crash. The dashed line is paying down a 4% mortgage instead. Every crash line ends above it — bad timing wasn’t fatal. Selling would have been.
Figured from the same 1928–2025 record used on this page — S&P 500 annual total returns (Damodaran). $10,000 in at the start of each peak year, dividends reinvested, in annual steps — so dips within a year don’t show. A lump sum is shown for the timing lesson; the plan itself invests monthly, which buys the falls as they come. The past record is not a forecast.